Login Register

Wind turbine would adversely affect Stithians Church, says Cornwall Council

By WBjridge  |  Posted: May 20, 2013

Comments (3)

Cornwall Council has refused permission for a 62m wind turbine on farmland at Stithians.
London-based Windberry energy Ltd wanted to build the turbine, with associated infrastructure and access track, at Pencoose Farm.
When the plans first came to light more than a year ago, local people set up an action group to fight the proposal.
They claimed the structure would be "the height of Truro Cathedral" and "a blot on the landscape".
It would be visible across the entire village, would adversely affect property prices and have a bad impact on the tourist trade.
Cornwall Council's planning department received 71 letters of objection and five of support.
Both Gwennap and Stithians parish councils refused to support the application.
The planning application was due to be considered by the west sub-area planning committee on June 3, but was turned down this week under delegated powers.
Planning officers concluded: "The proposed development, by virtue of its size, scale and location, would have a significant adverse landscape and visual impact, including an adverse impact on the setting of the Church of St Stedian  which is a Grade II Listed Building, in addition to dominating and adversely affecting the local landscape and the setting of the adjacent Area of Great Landscape Value and adding to the existing impact of tall, man-made structures."
Cornwall councillor Mark Kaczmarek, who represents Carharrack and Gwennap, said: "Following my discussions with planning officers dealing with the case, it will not now go to the West  Area planning committee on June 3.
"It has, I am pleased to say, been refused under delegated powers.
"I have also asked for a letter to be sent out informing all of those who had taken the time to write in to object or support the application just in case they were going to attend the meeting."

Read more from West Briton

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters


  • ChyTol  |  May 21 2013, 11:11AM

    This constitutes a welcome U turn by the council who were until recently backing the application (as evidenced in emails bewteen the Turbine Action Group and Cornwall Council Planning Dept). I would expect to see an appeal by the applicants. If you look at the applicants letters on the Cornwall Council planning portal where they object to the alleged nagative effect of the turbine on the landscape in such terms as "yes we would see a turbine, but does it matter?" (their actual words) then I conclude that the applicants were either very badly advised by third party experts or they are just stupid.

    |   1
  • toffer99  |  May 20 2013, 2:14PM

    Be prepared for the applicants to appeal this all the way up to the Minister. He is a Tory and will approve it as their policy is never deny development.

    |   2
  • willythefish  |  May 20 2013, 11:27AM

    Not often that we can say 'well done' to Cornwall Council, but this is one of those occasions so... WELL DONE!

    |   5