Login Register

Hayle unable to deny arch-rivals crucial derby win

By West Briton  |  Posted: December 27, 2012

Comments (0)

St Ives 18, Hayle 13

ST IVES survived a red card for flanker Sam Heath with 15 minutes remaining to see off old rivals Hayle in dreadful conditions at Alexandra Road, writes Nigel Walrond.

They maintained their winning record this season, but they missed out on a bonus point to leave them trailing Cornwall and Devon League leaders Teignmouth by two points, with 14 of their 26 league matches played.

St Ives head coach Joff Rowe said: "Hayle played very well and were certainly well prepared for the game, but the effort and hard work we put in enabled us to secure the win.

"My man of the match was Richard Humphries, who led from the front, but well done to all those who took part in a game played in appalling conditions."

Hayle put the home side under pressure from the kick-off, and after only two minutes they had a chance to open the scoring with a penalty, but the windy conditions proved too much and the opportunity was missed.


They continued to put pressure on the St Ives defence, who were struggling in the conditions to clear their lines, and turned their pressure into points when Scott Harvey crossed for a try after 12 minutes, converted by player-coach Martin Strick, to give Hayle a 7-0 lead.

Finding themselves behind for the first occasion in a long time this season, the St Ives players dug deep and began to get to grips with the weather, and they hit back just before the midway point in the first half when a catch-and-drive was finished off by captain and hooker Ben Taylor to make it 7-5 to Hayle.

The home side were punished once again by the boot of Strick after 23 minutes when he successfully kicked another penalty, but only three minutes later, Hayle were reduced to 14 men when scrum half Jamie Edwards was sent to the sin-bin for persistent offending around the scrum.

St Ives failed to capitalise on their extra man though, and it was Hayle who scored again with a Strick penalty to give them a 13-5 interval lead.

The second half proved to be a very different affair, with St Ives now enjoying the wind at their backs.

Only four minutes had elapsed when Taylor once again forced his way over the line to score his second try of the game, and St Ives were right back in it at only 13-10 down.

But it was St Ives' turn to then lose a player to the sin-bin, with former Pirates Amateurs flanker Heath receiving a yellow card.

However, while he was off, the Hakes took the lead for the first time in the match when Hayle old boy Jamie Prisk burst through the centre channel to score, and even though Thomas again missed the difficult conversion, St Ives had their noses in front at 15-13.

Heath returned to the fray, but his presence was only shortlived, as a large brawl resulted in Heath and Hayle centre Scott Murray both sin-binned for their part in the proceedings, and for Heath that was the end of his game.

The elements got even worse, with the mud becoming the clear winner, but with eight minutes remaining, Thomas finally conquered the conditions to slot a penalty to give his side some breathing space, and they saw out the rest of the game to seal a hard-fought victory.

Helston 12 Perranporth 15

With parts of Helston under water, it looked doubtful in the extreme that this rearranged Tribute Cornwall League One game would be able to go ahead.

However, a pitch inspection at 11am gave the green light for the match to proceed, though Helstonb director of coaching, Dave "Daisy" Adams and first team manager Gary McStein, had to fill in two areas of standing water.

Helston found themselves down to an early score but rallied with a well taken try following a forward drive by flanker Craig Saunders to level the scores.

Then Perranporth went ahead again before too long with another unconverted try but on the stroke of half time prop Ed Maddern got onto the back of some classic driving forward play and crashed over under the posts to allow full back Calvin Warwick to convert his efforts and give Helston a half time lead of 12-10.

Turning around with the slope in ther favour, Helston were hoping to take the game to Perranporth but were pinned back in their own 22 for long periods.

Eventually Perranporth scored wide out to give themselves a three point lead with another unconverted try.

However, Helston then managed to get field position and pressed strongly. No 8 Robin Cookson went close, as did skipper Ross Williams, but in the end the visitors held out for a hard fort victory.

Helston are in action at St Agnes on Saturday in a rearranged Tribute Cornwall Clubs' Cup fixture, weather permitting of course.

Read more from West Briton

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters