Login Register

Government's "hapless" flood response fails to convince voters

By GDemianyk  |  Posted: February 19, 2014

  • Flooding on the Somerset Levels

  • Government summit with insurers. Labour said: "Three hapless junior ministers booking a meeting room does not constitute a serious response to the flooding crisis."

Comments (6)

The Government’s “hapless” handling of the flooding crisis risks causing damage in the elections as the aftermath continues to cause concern in the Westcountry.

Labour yesterday criticised a much-vaunted Downing Street summit with insurers as polling indicated dissatisfaction with the Whitehall response from voters.

But Conservative and Liberal Democrat MPs praised the hands-on approach by David Cameron and Nick Clegg, who have repeatedly visited the flood-hit South West, in contrast to Labour’s botched command of the foot-and-mouth crisis in 2001, another major emergency to strike the South West.

The political row emerged against the backdrop of an analysis in The Times suggesting many flooded towns and cities visited by ministers were in marginal seats the Conservatives and Lib Dems were looking to win, so any misstep could cause damage at the ballot box.

While flood waters start to recede, questions remain over clear-up costs, insurance premiums and the future of transport links in the South West with the mainline at Dawlish still down. Engineers will tomorrow announce when the revised completion date is expected and a select committee probe next week examines the region’s vulnerable links.

Flooding Minister Dan Rogerson, also Lib Dem MP for North Cornwall, said talks with the insurance industry on getting help to those affected were “very reassuring”. Labour questioned the motivation for the meeting, claiming it was a “vacuous PR stunt”.

Michael Dugher, Labour’s Shadow Minister for the Cabinet Office, said: “Three hapless junior ministers booking a meeting room does not constitute a serious response to the flooding crisis.”

Mr Rogerson was labelled the “invisible minister” by one Sunday tabloid newspaper after taking a low profile amid the crisis as the Prime Minister and Cabinet colleagues were presented to national media in recent weeks.

The Somerset Levels were underwater for weeks before Mr Cameron last week announced “money was no object” to deal with flood relief as the disaster engulfed the west and south of England. But the message was undermined after Transport Secretary Patrick McLoughlin indicated there was “no blank cheque” for future resilience.

A ComRes poll for ITV News has found a sharp drop in the number of people who approve of the Government’s handling of the floods.

Sixty-two per cent do not think the Government and environmental agencies have responded well to the flooding an increase of 23 points since January 6. Sixty-three per cent think that the Government is emerging from the extreme weather with a worse reputation for crisis management.

But The Times piece was dismissed by many as only a handful of the marginal seats visited will see one of the parties of Government go up against Labour.

Ben Bradshaw, Labour MP for Exeter, an environment minister during the 2007 floods, said it is vital in a crisis like floods that the Prime Minister takes charge from the start, that the Government response is quick and effective and that ministers speak with one voice.

But he added: “None of this has happened during this winter’s floods and storms and the public have noticed.”

Andrew George, Lib Dem MP for St Ives, who accompanied the Deputy Prime Minister on a visit last to Cornwall last week, said the “political blame game is an unhelpful distraction and should be put to one side”, and argued given Labour’s handling of the foot -and-mouth crisis it shows the party has a “brass neck and a short-term memory”.

Mr George, an MP in 2001, said: “It should not be a party political issue, it should be about the country pulling together – to help those that need help.

“Rather than sit in oak-panelled rooms in Whitehall, the Government has done the right thing in pulling on the wellies and cagoules.”

Gary Streeter, Conservative MP for South West Devon, who was also in Parliament during foot-and-mouth, said: “I think since the Prime Minister has taken control it has been handled extremely well.

“But I think if you have been dramatically affected as they have in the Somerset Levels you are not going to get any credit if you are a politician.”

He said the response was much quicker than in 2001 “probably because most Conservative and Liberal Democrat MPs are from countryside constituencies and Labour are not”. He added: “Aside from the pictures on television, foot-and-mouth may as well have been on another planet given the reaction it.”

Related news

Amazing pictures show how storm created new 'beach' - as clean up effort continues

Fishing industry welcomes aid pledge at boats get back to sea

Insurers summoned to Downing Street flooding summit

£3,000 each a week and counting - the mounting cost of floods on Somerset businesses

NEW PICTURES: Dawlish and Exminster flooding from above, and Teignmouth's wrecked beach huts

PICTURES: Seaweed mountain washes up on beach near Plymouth

New threat to Westcountry's Easter trade if Dawlish rail repairs are delayed

In my opinion: Floods show that our lifestyle is ruining the planet

VIDEO AND PICTURES: Damage to beach cafe near Plymouth is revealed

VIDEO: MoD bills council £17,000 for Calstock cars rescue

Flooding crisis to see A303 upgrade fast-tracked

 

Read more from West Briton

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters

6 comments

  • josdave  |  February 19 2014, 8:39PM

    Funny how quickly they send money to foreign countries who suffer disasters and drag their feet when their own people are under the cosh.

    Rate   2
    Report
  • Charlespk  |  February 19 2014, 12:45PM

    That of course should be flood 'PLAINS' not planes.

    Rate   7
    Report
  • Charlespk  |  February 19 2014, 12:42PM

    If the Labour Government hadn't left this country nearly bankrupt, and we weren't cursed by the EU Directives about flood planes. . And we didn't have an incompetent Labour peer heading the Environment Agency, things would be a lot better. . It's time they were thought of as 'Lowland Planes that will flood if not properly drained', not nature reserves for environmentalists and Beaver lovers.

    Rate   5
    Report
  • Barri  |  February 19 2014, 12:15PM

    If "we are all in this together" and transparency was promised in the Flooding and Water Management Act - Why the secrecy in Government/ABI meetings and why are the minutes exempt from FOI requests ?

    Rate   -11
    Report
  • Charlespk  |  February 19 2014, 9:27AM

    It's all the Labour luvvies that now infest these quangos like Natural England and the Environment Agency, combined with these continual, infernal EU Directives that are the main problem.

    Rate   5
    Report
  • A_P_Bruton  |  February 19 2014, 8:04AM

    What wouldn't be "hapless" is if the government took seriously the call to prevent the vulnerability of Plymouth and Cornwall to isolation caused by their dependence on the Dawlish rail line. There is a petition on the government's own website calling for a second, inland rail link from Exeter to Plymouth. Link to petition here: http://tinyurl.com/oxk5f66

    Rate   6
    Report

      YOUR COMMENTS AWAITING MODERATION

       
       

      MORE NEWS HEADLINES