Login Register

Falmouth plan is 'too difficult' says PM

By West Briton  |  Posted: December 20, 2012

Comments (0)

THE Prime Minister has cited the delay in dredging Falmouth harbour as an example of how projects that could boost the economy are put in the "too difficult" box.

But in a joint statement, the Falmouth Bay and Harbour Action Group, Falmouth Friends of the Earth, the Marine Conservation Society and CPRE Cornwall have criticised his comments and said he had a "warped view" of the licensing procedure.

The £20 million scheme is part of a wider masterplan for the port, but the Marine Management Organisation (MMO), which has to give permission for the dredge, has so far blocked the scheme because of environmental fears.

It is currently the subject of a trial dredge to try and provide evidence that a full dredge to create a deep-water channel will not have an undue effect on the seabed, in particular on maerl beds.

That will conclude next year, when the MMO will make a final decision.

David Cameron told the Liaison Committee of MPs: "Often the problem can be solved, but it's put into the too difficult box, like in the case of dredging Falmouth harbour, where we raise these things at cabinet level in order to try and get departments to bring up things that they are blocking and explain why they are blocking them and see if we can find a way through it."

The statement from opponents said: "We are very concerned with the Prime Minister's recent comments. He exhibits a worrying view of the licensing procedure in which approval is the only correct and proper outcome.

"If consent for a project is not forthcoming, his comments imply that this can only be because environmental agencies are not doing their jobs properly.

"If Sainsbury's wanted to build a supermarket on the site of Stonehenge, everyone would grasp instinctively that this should never be allowed.

"People who understand and respect the marine environment see the proposed dredging of the Fal estuary and the associated plan to dump of one million tonnes of dredge-spoil in Falmouth Bay in the same way.

"The Fal's maerl beds (coralline seaweed), which are threatened by the dredging, are at least as old as Stonehenge and every bit as special as they are unique in England.

"The other worrying aspect of the PM's statement is that it puts inappropriate political pressure on the Marine Management Organisation.

"The MMO is legally obliged to decide the matter on a strictly precautionary and scientific basis. The PM should listen, have a view by all means, but let the MMO do its job, and come to an independent decision based on the likely impacts, without political interference.

"The PM's statement is yet further evidence that his pledge to lead the 'greenest government ever' was deeply misleading.

"What this government clearly wants is development at any cost."

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters
  • Dalex  |  December 21 2012, 12:55AM

    Not Surprising. Perhaps now is the time to apply wider lobbying of Cornwall Councillors. Kevin Lavery, Cornwall CEO, is nominated for the CEO of Wellington NZ City Authority. Perhaps he well get a welcome Haka from the All Blacks? In his support for outsourcing of Council Services and the secret allocation of £23 million of Taxpayers Money to fund the proposed Falmouth dredge project, he deserves to be welcomed in far away places. Central government cuts Local Authority funding. Cornwall Council cuts core local services, but David Cameron thinks that this project is in the "too difficult box". He's absolutely right. Nothing whatsoever to do with the environment - 1000 percent to do with irresponsible allocation of our money to support private enterprise. Private enterprise that is unwilling to spend its' own money and also having been refused funding from Europe. Use your own money A&P, and save David Cameron worry and angst in Cabinet!

    Rate   1