Login Register

Asda Penryn loses pharmacy planning appeal

By WBgdavies  |  Posted: April 22, 2013

Penryn Asda loses pharmacy planning appeal

Comments (2)

Asda has lost its appeal to open a controversial pharmacy at its Penryn store.

The company appealed against Cornwall Council's refusal to lift a condition to enable it to have a pharmacy counter.

That condition was attached to its 2008 planning permission to add a mezzanine floor to the supermarket.

The Council ruled it would be detrimental to the town centre as it could cause the pharmacy in Market Street to close if it went ahead.

This is part-operated by Hendra and Penryn Surgery and they said sales had already fallen since Asda opened and just a further 10 per cent reduction would leave the firm operating at a loss.

In December Asda put a portable building in the car park and began running a counter without permission, but no planning enforcement action was taken as the council wanted to wait for the outcome of the appeal.

A petition with more than 850 names was submitted against the scheme.

Planning inspector JM Trask dismissed the appeal this week.

He said: "It is likely it would result in a reduction in trade at the town centre pharmacy, which would be likely to prejudice its viability.

"The town centre is fragile and the loss of one of the few core businesses would have a significant adverse impact on the vitality and viability of Penryn."

Read more from West Briton

Do you have something to say? Leave your comment here...

max 4000 characters


  • jimjams2011  |  April 22 2013, 6:59PM

    Absolutely ridiculous that the council can prevent another business from selling what it likes. This is really anti-competitive and very worrying considering the other story about the ice cream shops pushing out a new start up from st ives. adapt or die.

    |   -1
  • toffer99  |  April 22 2013, 2:11PM

    What's the betting Asda will appeal, and as soon as the minister spots "Asda" on the paperwork he'll rubber-stamp it "yes". Don't underestimate this government of millionaires. As a rough guide, look for the most malevolent course of action, or one which favours business or the rich. That's the one they'll choose.

    |   6